10303 · 10301 · 10305Coldwell Banker Advantage

Published November 1, 2026 in Market Update

South Shore sales rose even with fewer homes for sale

By Chris DiToro
Real estate, South Shore

More homes sold on the South Shore even though there were fewer to choose from. That tells you demand is real. But Realtor.com reported that 21.6% of South region listings had price cuts in September 2026. Not every home is getting a free pass.

South Shore at a glance, three months ending August 31, 2026
Homes sold
up 7.8% from a year before
Homes for sale
down 10.1% from a year before
New listings
up 3.7% from a year before
Pending sales
down 2.6% from a year before
Source: Real Estate Data Aggregator, the three months ending August 31, 2026

Sales rose while inventory shrank. That is the core story for the South Shore right now. Buyers had fewer choices, yet more deals closed. Pricing and condition are doing the sorting.

What the price-cut signal means

Realtor.com reported that 21.6% of South region listings carried a price cut in September 2026. That is more than one in five. At the same time, Realtor.com put mortgage rates above 7% that month. Higher rates stretch budgets, and sellers who price too high are feeling it first.

South region listings with a price cut, September 2026
Source: Realtor.com, Sep 30, 2026

The Federal Housing Finance Agency reported U.S. house prices rose 2.4% from August 2025 to August 2026. The South Shore is doing better than that in several ZIP codes, as the numbers below show. But the national trend is a reminder that gains are not automatic.

How each ZIP code performed

The South Shore covers five ZIP codes. They do not all move the same way. Here is what the Real Estate Data Aggregator counted for the three months ending August 31, 2026.

The stories behind the numbers

ZIP 10312 led the Shore in volume. The Real Estate Data Aggregator counted 172 homes sold there, up 6.8%. The median sale price rose 5.9% to $799,500. Supply fell to just 2.6 months. That is a tight market.

ZIP 10309 had the biggest jump in sales, up 29.4% to 88 homes. But the median sale price dipped 6.7% to $786,750. Days on market stretched to 47, nine days longer than a year before. More homes sold, but buyers pushed back on price.

ZIP 10307 saw inventory fall 18.8% while sales rose 18.8%. Days on market dropped 21 days. The median sale price was $967,500, the highest on the Shore. Homes there are moving faster and selling closer to asking.

ZIP 10308 had the fastest median close at 28 days, 7 days quicker than a year before. Nearly 1 in 3 homes sold above list price. Inventory did rise 23.2% there, so buyers have a little more room to look.

ZIP 10306 saw sales slip just 1.7% while the median price rose 5.4% to $775,000. Days on market fell 5 days. The share of homes selling above list price rose 8.1 points to 29.3%.

One thing every South Shore buyer should know

If you are looking below the boulevard, flood insurance is a real ownership cost. It is not optional for most homes on the water side of Hylan Boulevard. Factor it into your monthly budget before you fall in love with a price.

Days on market by ZIP code

Median days on market, three months ending August 31, 2026
10308 – Staten Island, NY28 days10306 – Staten Island, NY33 days10307 – Staten Island, NY33 days10312 – Staten Island, NY39 days10309 – Staten Island, NY47 days
Real Estate Data Aggregator. Lower is faster. ZIP 10308 had the shortest wait; ZIP 10309 the longest.

Sold above list price

Share of homes that sold above list price, three months ending August 31, 2026
10308 – Staten Island, NY32.9%10309 – Staten Island, NY29.6%10306 – Staten Island, NY29.3%10307 – Staten Island, NY29%10312 – Staten Island, NY28.5%
Real Estate Data Aggregator. Nearly 3 in 10 homes across the Shore sold for more than the asking price.
In short
  1. The South Shore sold more homes in the three months ending August 31, 2026, even with fewer listings on the market.
  2. But more than 1 in 5 South region listings needed a price cut by September 2026, according to Realtor.com.
  3. Demand is there.
  4. Pricing to the market, not above it, is what separates the homes that close from the ones that sit.

These are ZIP code averages. One block, one street or one building can read very differently from the whole. If you want to know where your specific address stands, reach out and I will show you.

Your next step

(917) 586-3158

Text me your address and I will send back what your South Shore home looks like against what actually sold near you in the three months ending August 31, 2026. Takes a day, costs nothing.

Text me
Where these numbers came from